Comparative evaluation of Mehsana buffalo bulls by simple daughter and contemporary comparison methods using first lactation milk yield
Title: Comparative evaluation of Mehsana buffalo bulls by simple daughter and contemporary comparison methods using first lactation milk yield
Authors: JD Chaudhari, JP Gupta, DP Pandey, GA Parmar, BM Prajapati, MN Prajaparti and PA Patel
Source: Ruminant Science (2018)-7(1):51-54.
Cite this reference as: Chaudhari JD, Gupta JP, Pandey DP, Parmar GA, Prajapati BM, Prajaparti MN and Patel PA (2018). Comparative evaluation of Mehsana buffalo bulls by simple daughter and contemporary comparison methods using first lactation milk yield. Ruminant Science 7(1):51-54.
The data for the present study comprised 8072 first lactation records of Mehsana buffaloes, sired by 182 bulls, spread over a period of 25 years (1989-2013) under field progeny testing programme of Dudhsagar Research and Development Association (DURDA), Dudhsagar Dairy, Mehsana, Gujarat, India. The breeding values of Mehsana buffalo bulls were estimated for first lactation milk yield (FL305MY) and total milk yield (TMY) by simple daughter average index (D) and contemporary comparison (CC) methods. The average breeding values for FL305MY by D and CC were 2252.78 and 2247.67 litres; however, the corresponding average breeding values by these methods for TMY were 1897.82 and 1916.19 litres, respectively. The rank correlation coefficients between breeding values of sires by D and CC methods for FL305MY and TMY were found as 0.998 and 0.944, respectively. This shows that this both the methods could rank the sires with fairly high accuracy, when evaluation is done for FL305MY. Estimates of breeding value of Mehsana buffalo further revealed that performance of this breed is comparable with the well established buffalo breeds of India and there is a need to carry out more work to harness the potential of this breed in future.
Chaudhari PN, Upadhyay MR, Patel AC, Patel SB and Rank DN (2015). A comparison of different methods of sire evaluation for production and reproduction traits of Murrah graded buffaloes. Indian Journal of Dairy Science 68(3):259-265.
DAHD (2009). Minimum Standards for Progeny Testing. Department of Animal Husbandry, Dairying and Fisheries Ministry of Agriculture and Farmers Welfare, Government of India. p 58.
Edwards J (1932). The progeny test as a method of evaluating the dairy sire. Journal of Agricultural Science 22:811-837.
ICAR (2014). International Committee for Animal Recording, International Agreement of Recording Practices, Approved by the General Assembly held in Berlin, Germany. pp 91-92.
Jain A and Sadana DK (2000). Sire evaluation using animal model and conventional methods in Murrah buffaloes. Asian-Australasian Journal of Animal Sciences 13(9):1196-1200.
Kiplagat SK, Limo MK and Kosgey SI (2012). Genetic improvement of livestock for milk production. In: Milk Production-Advanced Genetic Traits, Cellular Mechanism, Animal Management and Health, Eds: N Chaiyabutr. Intech Open, Winchester. pp 77-96.
Kumar A, Gandhi RS and Haile A (2011). Estimation of variance components of milk yield and genetic evaluation of Sahiwal cattle using mixed linear models. Indian Journal of Animal Sciences 81(6):605-609.
Kumar V (2012). Genetic impact of progeny testing programme under network project on Murrah buffalo improvement. PhD Thesis submitted to National Dairy Research Institute, Karnal.
Kumar V, Chakravarty AK, Patil CS, Shivahre PR and Gupta A (2015). Comparison among different conventional methods of sire evaluation in Murrah buffalo. Indian Journal of Animal Sciences 85(6):670-673.
Mir MA, Kumar M and Vohra V (2015). Factors affecting quality dairy Bulls production in India. Applied Research Journal 1(4):197-200.
Singh M, Singh A, Gupta AK, Chakravarty AK, Prakash V, Singh A and Sahoo S (2014). Relative effectiveness of best linear unbiased prediction-animal model vis-à-vis other sire evaluation methods for genetic evaluation of Murrah sires. Indian Journal of Dairy Science 67(6):510-514.
Singh PK, Kumar S, Goel R and Singh SP (2013). Genetic studies on some production traits in Sahiwal cows. Ruminant Science 2(2):201-203.
Singh PK and Singh BP (1999). Efficacy of different methods in genetic evaluation of Murrah sires. The Indian Journal of Animal Sciences 69(12):1044-1047.
Steel RGD and Torrie JH (1981). Principles and Procedures of Statistics-A Biometrical Approach. 2nd Edn, McGrew Hill Book Company Inc. Tokyo. p 633.
Sundaresan D, Gurnani M and Sidhu SP (1965). Evaluation of breeding value of bulls used in two herds in India. Indian Journal of Dairy Science 48(11):1498-1497.